New Plants Shaped the Nineteenth Century English Garden

Eighteenth century England witnessed a garden built on aesthetic theory, especially the picturesque.

In the picturesque view a landscape gardener depicted the landscape in plants, stone, and water much as nature would.  Such a view, if done in taste, could result in a sense of awe in the onlooker. Andre Rogger writes in his book Landscapes of Taste, which is about the late eighteenth century landscape gardener Humphy Repton, “Exercising the rule of taste, was, for Repton, the principal duty of the professional landscape gardener.” 

Horticulturist, landacpe gadenr, and writer John Claudius Loudon

Horticulturist, landscape gardener, and writer John Claudius Loudon

Unfortunately, John Claudius Loudon (1783-1843), a disciple of Repton, though he treasured that view of the landscape, developed his own landscape theory, called the gardenesque, centered on the idea that the modern landscape was a place to showcase plants.

Rogger writes, “Loudon’s ‘Gardenesque’ school designs were no longer shaped by aesthetic theories but by the science of horticulture and botany.”

By the early nineteenth century, when Loudon was in his prime, plants were coming into England from around the world, including the Americas, Africa, and Asia.

The wealthy aristocrat, of course, wanted to display the new plants he had acquired as does anyone who believes that the garden reflects and creates a sense of fashion for a particular time and place. The collecting of plants became the popular gardening style.

Loudon was simply responding to the current interest in botany with its focus on the study of plants. Thus it was no surprise that annuals, many from warmer climates, replaced the earlier use of perennials in the English garden.

New plants shaped the nineteenth century English garden.



  1. I’m curious: what was unfortunate about Loudon developing this style? Why shouldn’t gardens look man-made?

    • The 18th century prevailing landscape view prior to Loudon was the natural or picturesque look, which meant the look of nature, not that of the earlier formal, symmetrical look. Loudon wanted the picturesque look, but also wanted to showcase the new trees and shrubs and other plants coming into England at that time. He recommended a Pinetum, or Arboretum, for that purpose, and that landscape design he called ‘gardenesque’, which he distinguished from both the ancient (or formal) and the natural. Devotees of the natural look did not want the landscape to look like a person had designed it. The intent was to have the landscape appear ‘as if it was always there.’ That, of course, is something you cannot do with a formal or architectural design since it clearly shows the handiwork of a landscape gardener or landscape architect.

Speak Your Mind